namake.

Lesson 75: Giving practical advice

Give focused advice using Vたほうがいいです and Vないほうがいいです.

Giving practical advice

Lesson 53: た form; lesson 54: ない form; lessons 50/62/63: prohibition, request and obligation. Start with the first example and short meaning question. Vocabulary help, reading support and audio are available; try first yourself. All people and plans are fictional.

1 · Advising a better choice

A fictional learner does not understand an assignment and is choosing between guessing and asking the teacher. 先生に聞いたほうがいいです recommends asking as the better choice. に marks whom you ask here. First find the action being recommended.

The advice compares doing with not doing, or with a less favourable choice. It is fairly direct: use a concrete reason. It is not a universal formula for every casual recommendation. です makes the ending polite, but does not make every unsolicited recommendation appropriate.

先生に聞いたほうがいいです。

2 · The た form does not mean past tense here

Take the た form from lesson 53 and add ほうがいいです: 聞く→聞いたほうがいいです, 行く→行ったほうがいいです. Remember the familiar exception 行く→行った.

Within this advice pattern, た does not mean the action has already happened. For an appointment tomorrow, 早く行ったほうがいいです can still be advice about the future. The entire construction determines the meaning.

早く行ったほうがいいです。

3 · Better not do it

For negative advice, use the ない form, not a negative past form: 買う→買わないほうがいいです. A learner is considering a pen that is too expensive; 今、買わないほうがいいです advises against buying it now.

Positive advice in this lesson uses Vた; negative advice uses Vない. Do not simply put ません after a ます form, and do not add ほう after です.

今、買わないほうがいいです。

4 · Advice, rather than a fixed duty

For a busy route to an appointment, going early is a sensible choice: 早く行ったほうがいいです. This is the speaker’s advice. A school rule or explicit obligation uses the constructions from lesson 50 or 63.

Advice does not prove the listener follows it. The listener may decide otherwise. Practise practical school and travel situations; these language exercises do not address medical problems.

このペンを使わないほうがいいです。

All lessons